Can the crew keep a surprise secret from another guest?

Answer

The crew can generally work discreetly with the person arranging a surprise, provided the request is practical and appropriate.

Advance planning is particularly important because provisioning, deliveries, decorations and other arrangements may otherwise reveal the surprise.

The broker can help establish a discreet communication process before embarkation.

Analysis

The easiest surprises are planned before guests arrive. Once everyone is onboard, physical logistics and shared spaces can make secrecy more difficult.

Communication should therefore be agreed in advance.

Broker’s advice

If something is genuinely secret, tell us that from the beginning. We can help keep the planning discreet and minimise the number of people who need to know.